Skip to content

Why I Stopped Believing in the Elevator Pitch (and You Can Too)

Why I Stopped Believing in the Elevator Pitch (and You Can Too)
elevator pitch

If you’ve ever been told you need an elevator pitch — a perfectly polished 30-second explanation of your business — and felt instant resistance, you’re not alone. I have that feeling too.

For many business owners, the elevator pitch feels forced, fake, awkward, and wildly disconnected from how real conversations actually happen. It’s hard to be short and slick when what you really want is to be understood.

One time, many years ago, a man passed through my front gate. My dogs were in the yard and started to happily bark at the arrival of a visitor. Peering out the window to see who it was, I saw a man getting attacked with love and affection from my two yellow labs. He was laughing and smiling and trying to break free from their welcome. Seconds later, I learned that man was running for city council and going door-to-door to meet the community asking for support on voting day. That man was Mark Mullet, who ended up winning a seat on city council and since worked in the 5th Legislative District for Washington State Senate and now running for City Mayor in Issaquah, WA.  

I knew nothing about that man. I didn't know his resume, where he worked, his credentials, nothing. From that day forward, he had my vote. Luckily, we share similar values and his position, but his elevator pitch was that moment with my dogs.  It happened organically and naturally and had absolutely nothing to do with his campaign. I carry this story with me always on the power of marketing and the irrelevance of an elevator pitch.

Here’s the truth: you don’t need a pitch. You need clarity — and confidence.

The problem with the elevator pitch

Elevator pitch culture assumes a few things:

  • People are ready to listen on demand
  • A short, scripted explanation wins attention
  • Confidence comes from memorization

But in real life, most people aren’t standing in an elevator waiting to be impressed. They’re busy. Distracted. Curious — maybe — but not captive. When business owners launch into rehearsed lines, it often creates distance instead of connection.

The underlying issue isn’t the words — it’s the pressure to perform instead of communicate.

Confidence changes everything

Here’s the piece people often overlook: most of the stress around “pitching” comes from not knowing yourself as a business owner.

Confidence isn’t something you conjure in the moment — it’s something that grows from clarity:

  • clarity about who you help
  • clarity about the value you provide
  • clarity about what makes you you
  • clarity about how to communicate that naturally

When you understand these fundamentals, talking about your business stops feeling like a performance. Conversational explanations replace scripted pitches. Confidence grows because your message isn’t something you recite — it’s something you believe.

Where my work fits into this

Most of the business owners I work with don’t need tighter elevator pitches — they need a stronger foundation. That’s why I built tools like the Full Visibility Audit + Strategy Deep Dive.

This isn’t about pretty logos alone — it’s about helping you know your business from the inside out:

  • a discovery conversation that explores what you truly offer
  • clarity about your vision, values, and audience
  • a brand guide that reflects that clarity
  • visual elements you can use with confidence

When those pieces are in place, your confidence grows — not because you memorize something, but because you can articulate it naturally whenever someone asks.

The shift: from pitching to being understood

The goal isn’t to convince someone of your value in 30 seconds. The goal is to make it easy for the right people to recognize themselves in your work.

And that happens long before you ever speak — it happens:

  • on your website
  • in your social presence
  • in how your visuals and words reflect your value
  • in how clearly your brand communicates your purpose

When clarity and confidence are present, the “pitch” becomes unnecessary. Conversations become comfortable. People start saying, “Oh — that’s exactly what I need.”

If you hate the elevator pitch, trust that instinct

Discomfort is often a signal — not that you’re bad at business, but that you’re trying to use a tool that doesn’t fit how you communicate. You don’t need a rehearsed line. You need clarity and confidence.

And when those are in place?
Pitching becomes easy — not because you practice it, but because you believe it.